Web Analytics Made Easy -

Menus + Add Menu

Gallery Add Photos

Reviews Add Review

"While visiting Rosario's Cigar,my fiance'and Iwalked to Goodfella'sto try the pizza. It began to rain and we decided to eat there but were informed by the manager that we could not since we had not been charged the dine in charge. We asked if we could just pay the cost or purchase another menu item since it was pouring raining by this time and were informed that this was not an option and that the owner monitored the video tapes for the restaurant. This was very upsetting and we hope it was not because the color of our skin."

"May 20, 2022"

"Went to Goodfellas on victory blvd in Staten Island. Not sure of my experience I will let you decide. While out shopping for cigars up the street. Me and my fiancé stopped by for some pizza. While she went inside I waited outside smoking a cigar. She ordered to go. However she paid for the pizza and it started to rain. As a result we decided to dine in and the manager informed us we couldn’t because we weren’t charged for dining in. At which time we informed him we would either pay the charge or place another order to dine in. At this time it was pouring down raining. The manager then informed us that neither was an option and the owner watches on camera. However nevertheless the pizza was ok. Which is more than what I can say about the hospitality. However you decide but I won’t be recommending this place to no one. Last but not least I hope it wasn’t because of my complexion or nationality."

"May 20, 2022"

Sponsored ads nearby

2 For $22 Coal Fired Pizza

Pizzeria 0 Miles Away


Italian 0 Miles Away

Lobster House Joes (see both locations)

Seafood,Lobster, 0 Miles Away

Tuesday Dine In Special: All Appetizers 1/2 Price w/Purchase of any Entree!...

0 Miles Away

Info about Content Below

See what people are saying Write Review View All Reviews

Location & Details

Goodfella's Victory Located in Castleton Corners neighborhood of Staten Island. Goodfella's Victory is open Today. Wednesday March 29th from 11:30 am -until 09:30 pm Delivery, is available. Serving Pizzeria Cuisine

1817 Victory Blvd. ,

1877 Victory Blvd ,
1734 Victory Blvd,
1734 Victory Blvd. ,
2048 Victory Boulevard ,
20 Bradley Ave , 10314
1210 Forest Avenue ,
676 Forest Avenue,
1351 Forest Avenue, NY 10302
1495 Forest Avenue ,
1495 Forest Ave., NY 10302
1400 Clove Road ,
1640 Forest Avenue,

WhereYouEat.com Near Me Search
Discover Local Restaurants